What If YouTube Music Succeeds?
What happens if YouTube DOESN'T Succeed? Let's talk about it.
Join us for an eye-opening journey into the future of podcasting in this episode titled "What if YouTube Podcasts Succeeds?" As we navigate the swirling currents of possibilities, your hosts, Daniel J. Lewis and Dave Jackson dive into a sea of burning questions and bold predictions.
What would the long-term repercussions be in a world where Google Podcasts outruns its competitors? The hosts will consider this scenario, examining potential outcomes and opportunities for creators and users.
We share his firsthand experience with YouTube Music, giving a quick test to understand the user interface and the integration of podcasts. Meanwhile, Dave brings the perspective of audiobooks on Spotify to the table, drawing comparisons and outlining the benefits and caveats of diversifying content types.
Indulge in a thought experiment with us — "What If It Was Good?" — contemplating the ideal scenario of Google mastering podcast integration.
Your Hosts
Find Dave at schoolofpodcasting.com
Find Daniel at theaudacitytopodcast.com
NEW TO BITCOIN?
Check out our resources at
leadingthebleeding.com/resources
FOLLOW THE SHOW
Apple - Spotify - Podcast Guru - Castomatic
Support The Show
Daniel
Podgagement - Boost Your Audience Engagement
Social Subscribe and Follow Plugin
Dave
Mentioned In This Episode
Million Dollar Weekend Book (aff)
FOLLOW THE SHOW ON A MODERN PODCAST APP
0:00 What if YouTube Podcasts actually succeeds? Well, you know, YouTube is trying to make this big push into what they think are podcasts. And we've talked about the whole thing of what is a podcast is, what YouTube doing, actually podcasting, all of that. I I actually want to put that aside for now and not debate definitions, but instead just look at what if this actually takes off? What if what they're calling YouTube podcasting actually becomes popular. Like, we look at Google Podcasts and some of the percentages were, what, 1%, 5%. You know, not in the top apps, but close. Right. So what if YouTube overtakes that and becomes a major destination for what we actually know as podcasts. I'm not saying, like, the stuff that's only video on YouTube being called a podcast. We're not talking about definitions, but what if people actually go to YouTube for their podcasts in the
1:33 future and all the podcasts are on YouTube And what if that happens? That's interesting. The thing that's gonna be because I was thinking about what's the difference between Google Podcasts and a YouTube podcast. Yeah. Well, the biggest one is YouTube is sucking in your media file, and that's it. So you get one download from YouTube, YouTube Music, whatever we're gonna call it. And so it's going to be hard. Libsyn and Buzzsprout and these other places, they could look at the user agent and say, wow. We've got an x amount of thousands of downloads from this user agent. This puts it as the number 3 app.
2:16 And I don't know how we're gonna do that unless I know at Podcast Movement Evolutions, they did mention that they have an API. Now what I don't know is if that is somehow because I don't know anything about API. I don't know anything about crypto. I don't know anything about APIs. But if that somehow feeds back information I mean, if you think about it, the early days and let's please not repeat this history. The early days of Spotify, they ingested your file and then fed back Spotify stats. I hope that's not where we're going with YouTube because in the end, it Or remember what Stitcher did for a while, where they also ingested your file. They rehosted it. They re encoded it. But they eventually did this thing where whenever someone would press play on their version of your file, they would also send some sort of ping over to your podcast hosting provider hosted file so that it could track the download. Now, this was before the IAB guidelines which required a certain amount to be downloaded for account. But there was that approach too. Yeah. So it's gonna be hard to to judge. And again, it's it's really hard for me to put the definition thing aside, but when they say a report and they say a podcast, podcasting on YouTube is now such and such, there is that side of me that goes, well, is it a podcast, or is it a YouTube podcast, or whatever we're gonna call it? So that's been my biggest gripe and about that is, well, how are we going to measure things then if if things
3:49 are a little blurry? But it would be interesting to see. I did spend about 20 minutes, which doesn't sound like a long time. It is when you're just looking at an app that you're going, yeah. No. No. You know? And I I played with YouTube Music, and I was like, yeah. I'm not. And and both YouTube Music and Spotify, they have they're cramming everything in there. Like, I was listening to a pretty good book by the guy that founded AppSumo, and it's called The $1,000,000 Weekend. And so I'm listening to him. Like, this is great. I might actually cancel my Audible subscription, and then I went to make a bookmark, and you can't. And I was like, this is these are the things you get when you are, you know, when you try to do everything.
4:38 Everything is, well, okay. Like, can I find podcasts in YouTube music? Yeah. Eventually, it's this tag thing, and you search, and everything's in video, and it's like so I I wish you know, for me, my my wish list would be you Spotify, you do music phenomenal. I pay for Spotify music. I love it. YouTube, you do video, great. Keep doing what you're doing. And, you know, Audible, you're great with audiobooks. You keep doing that because Audible has over the years, you know, they we you can submit your show to Amazon and have it go into Audible, but it'll be it's gonna be hard to measure. Absolutely. And that point of the API thing. Now props to you tube and Libsyn for working together because there is actually an API that Libsyn has been able to use when you allow Libsyn to cross publish your episode over to YouTube.
5:30 And it's only when you let Libsyn do it for you, then Libsyn is able to get stats back from YouTube. But that's only if you let Libsyn upload it for you. If you're uploading it yourself or if you're doing something even more advanced like making an actual video, even though your traditional audio podcast and please do not attack me for the terms I'm about to use. I'm only using them for the sake of conversation. Even if your traditional audio podcast is only audio and it's in all the podcast apps, and then you have a video, quote, podcast, unquote, on YouTube and it's full video, well, that means you have to upload that separately. But that needs a separate kind of callback in order to register those stats.
6:20 And and that point of you wouldn't really get to see it very well because the algorithms for just measuring engagement is very different. In podcasting, we have right now the IAB guidelines, which one of the major points of it is that one minute of audio must be downloaded chapters certain header information and data that's in the file. One minute of audio must be downloaded before it can be counted as a download. On YouTube, I think it's 10 seconds or 30 seconds must be played before that little play counter will tick up once and count that as a play. So right there, you have a completely different number, 30 seconds versus 1 minute. Now, that's nothing if someone actually consumes the entire episode. But when you're counting just mere numbers, and that's all that you're getting is this is the number, this is the download, well, then on YouTube, that's where you really have to look into the deeper stats. But if they could send that back to your podcast hosting provider, that could be great to see this is my actual consumption on YouTube. And as we also as I believe it was Dan Meisner who spoke about this and or Steven Goldstein, Several people actually have spoken about this is that it would be great if instead of just talking about downloads or downloads per episode or downloads per month or anything like that, if we instead talk about time listened. Or I would really say percentage listened might be better. That's the one I like. Yeah. Because if you've got a
7:51 5 minute episode, you wanna know that people are listening to all of it. You don't wanna know they JSON to 5 minutes. That's not an impressive number to say, hey, you know, I get 5 minutes listened per week. Now you want, I get 100% of my episodes listened every week. That kind of information, YouTube does track that with all of their videos, and you can see that if you go into your analytics for your videos, whether that's fake video, real video, fake podcast, whatever. Any of that, you can see that, but they're not reporting that back to your podcast hosting provider. And in fact, none of the podcast apps report that consumption data back to your hosting provider. Oh, yeah. It would be awesome if they did. That would it it would be so nice to have that all in one spot and add it all together, and that's that's where as close as, you know, the IAB guidelines are and things like that, you it's and everybody is really measuring things, not hugely different, but kind of.
8:46 I mean, Spotify, I think you have to listen to I don't think it's a well, no. Because they're IB certified. Well, Meg well, are they or are they not? I'd have to go to the dashboard. But, yeah, so it's everybody's a little different. We're very close, but we're also kind of different. It's not exact. And I think that goes back to the it's a guideline, not a standard. Like, the apps or games advertising for podcasts and generating basically fake downloads. Yeah. Not completely fake, but they're not completely real either. That kind of thing. There are ways to gain that too with Spotify. Like, here's the thing, just to point this out, the vulnerability here, Spotify allows you to rate a podcast. You can't write a review, but you can leave a rating for a podcast, but you must listen to the podcast before you do. And I think it's something like you must listen to 30 seconds. I I don't remember the exact number, but here's the trick.
9:43 Just click around in the timeline a few times, and you don't even have to listen to however many seconds it is. You just skip around, and then you can leave a rating. That's a vulnerability. That kind of thing needs to be patched. Yeah. And, you know, there's a really good solution for this, activity streams, which we'll do a separate episode to kind of put that whole conversation of activity streams into layman terms. But there is potential for that of something that could allow these apps if they wanted to. Some of them don't want to, and that's the bigger problem. But if they wanted to, they could report that consumption data.
10:24 Yeah. That would be, someday, you know. So here's another thought experiment with this. You mentioned that you spend about 20 minutes or so just getting frustrated with the app. What if YouTube, you or slash YouTube music, whatever, actually became a good audio podcast experience instead of this whole having to convert things over to fake video or anything like that. It it actually functions like an audio podcast app. What if that happens? That would be different. It'd be great on one hand. I'm all for what makes it easier for the listener. And so if this becomes a super easy playlist creative they've already got playlists, so, you know, just a a great app, and we've talked about before what we want in an app. That would be amazing.
11:16 I would love to to see that, because in the end, if it's too hard, if any app, then listeners aren't gonna be there. And I I heard where Edison Research came out, and now the average listener listens to I believe it's now up to 8 episodes a week, which is up from whatever previously was, so that was encouraging. And so if we can, you know, find something to make it easier and we get that up to 9 or 10 or whatever, that would be amazing. So I'm all, you know, I don't care what app. I I've I've been playing with Padurama, and I like it because the interface is easy, you know. So whatever app is is great, and you were playing with Cast o Matic, that's what I've been using for a while, and I'm still as soon as Podcast Guru gets that smart playlist, I'm I'm all over for jumping on that, but, it'd be great. I would love to see it. It it I thought about this as we were thinking about this topic. Because on one hand, it's really easy to go, look, we've had Google Reader. We had, you know, all these different Google products that they've been taken away. So it's really easy to go, well, based on their track record, this probably isn't gonna be a success.
12:25 But there is the flip side to that. They go, yeah, but the odds are kinda with them now because how many times can you fail? You know what I mean? It's like eventually, they're gonna figure out how to do something right, and I thought they had that with Google Podcasts. So You know, this is a flaw in the system, and maybe Adam would call this the the podcast industrial complex. And it's a flaw with open source as well, where you look at the way that Google does things and it's all proprietary software and all of that. And look at Android, their operating system for mobile devices. It's open source software. Anyone can use Android on their device if they want to. They can compile it, build it, do all this stuff. They can customize it, all of this stuff. They don't have to pay a licensing fee, anything like that. It's open source.
13:16 What does Google stand to gain by having podcasts? Well, like, Google Podcast app was not preinstalled. Its functionality was preinstalled, but the actual app icon was not preinstalled. They gained nothing from that. No monetary value. It's not enhancing the experience on Android because it wasn't obviously native. Whereas, compare that to Apple Podcasts on iOS. IOS is a closed system. You can get iOS only on Apple Devices. But they make all of these apps that make the whole device experience better. And the more Apple products you have, the better the experience gets because all your Apple products talk nicely to each other, synchronize, hand off things to each other, all of this stuff. So when Apple adds a feature, it increases the value of the experience of their products. Google Podcasts did not increase the value of Android. And you look then at YouTube, well, where Google stands to benefit from YouTube and podcasts on YouTube is their own advertising. So the unfortunate thing is, I think, at least the way that they currently have this built out, they have to make it monetized. They have to enable advertising in some way around the experience, inside your content like they do with YouTube videos sometimes. That's what they have to do because they put themselves in this corner where instead
14:49 of simply being an app that lets you download episodes from the RSS feed like an actual podcast app, they are rehosting the media. They're not only rehosting the MP Threes, the audio files, they are also converting those audio files into video to host fake video on their own platform. And the ratio of the size of video to audio is huge. Video bandwidth is so much more intensive. It takes so much more processing power to convert that. It takes so much more storage space. It's costing Google money to have brought podcasts to Google this way on YouTube, they have to make that money back or they are going to kill it again.
15:43 Google Podcasts didn't cost them anything or barely anything. I mean, it cost them the people, the time to create the product. But Right. That could be one person or a couple of people. For a while, it was. And for a while, look at how well it did. Even though it wasn't Yeah. The pre installed icon on the app. Even though it had all of these uphill hurdles and all of that, look at how well it did anyway. And it was so simple and it just worked. YouTube is different. Yeah. It has to be monetized for them. It has to pay these bills that they've shot themselves in the foot, put themselves in a corner, and shot themselves with this. They have to bite the bullet. Lots of violent analogies here. They have made this more difficult for themselves because now it's costing them. Now they have to make money from our content that we allow them to distribute on YouTube podcasts.
16:40 I'll wipe my mouth out later for that. So that makes me worried about the experience. But if they backtracked and turned it into something more like an actual podcast app, And they let people follow RSS feeds instead of YouTube channels. And they let people just get an audio focused experience, which I'm so disappointed in them. It's the biggest disappointment ever in podcasting to me, and it's the biggest flop, I think, right now at least. They could make it so much better. But right now, it's the biggest flop because they took the laziest, worst approach they could have done. And I I feel like with my scrappy development skills, I could have made something better in the amount of time that they've been hyping this up.
17:33 And Well, the other thing that makes me confused is Rob at Lipson reached out and said, hey. What happens when you click on a Google link now? Is it going to redirect to a YouTube music link? And you can go find your show in YouTube music and share it. So there is a link that will direct people to your show in YouTube music. And they were like, well, right now, nothing. Like, we're not doing anything. And then Rob said even though it was after April 1st, you could still I think he said you were able to play it. So even though they said it was shut down, you could still play it, but I don't think it's gonna play it. On and hold Google Podcast link. Yeah. So, like, if you didn't take it off your website, like, what would happen to it?
18:21 And, you know, the smart thing, if you want to really build your new app, you would just have it redirect where people could click on it and say, oh, I wanna follow this show Yes. In the new app. And instead, they they tried to train people on how to export an OPML file and import it into YouTube, and I was like, yeah, not the easiest path there where they could have just put in some sort of redirect, said the guy, of course, that doesn't do any programming, but I'm like, it sure seemed like an easy thing to do. They make both of these apps. They could have made a button that was just transferred to YouTube music, and and they could have just transferred that straight over. None of this download your OPML and then re upload it kinda thing, which is difficult enough to do on a mobile device. But I just checked my own link in the US when I visit my link that I have. I I've removed the icon from my site, but when I visit my secret link, then it takes me to a page that says Google Podcasts is no longer available. Listen to podcasts and build your library in the YouTube Music app. And there's a button to explore YouTube Music.
19:26 Nothing about where to get this podcast from, let alone even the name of the podcast someone just visited. In fact, the URL, yeah, it's now just podcast.google.com. It just redirects my old Google podcast link now just redirects to podcast.google.com with that page. That's disappointing. Yeah. So in the keeping score here, what if YouTube was big? That's kind of like, it sure doesn't look like they're they didn't think this through. Because the hardest thing I always tell people, if you start a new show so let's say I did a show about Star Trek, and I was just tired of talking about Star Trek, and I decided I'm gonna do a show about Star Wars. The stupidest thing you could do is not let your audience know, hey, if you like, you know, Star Trek, I'm gonna start a new show on Star Wars, and this one will stop because your audience might follow you.
20:21 And then if if you actually took the first show away, you could redirect it to the new show. And granted, there are some people like, I hate Star Wars. I don't want this. Well, fine. But at least you made it for your your listeners. They could either stay or go. And this just seems like why are you making it so hard? And I I also think look, we're we're nerds. Most of us that listen to the show are nerds. So we can export an OPML and import. It's no big deal. But I don't think the general public that went over their heads. And I I know in support, I've had people like, hey, what happened to Google Podcasts? Because they're not nerds. They're not running in this circle, and I've been pointing to, like, here's, you know, Podcast Goori, here's Padurama, here's Podcast Addict, you know, and then when you start mentioning feeds, they're like, what what is this weird voodoo you are speaking of? So they, again, they kinda missed a boat. So it'd be great. I would love to see it again soar, but the you know, your first impression is is not a great one right now. As when I heard that, I was like, oh, are you kidding me? They're not doing they're just setting you to a dead end here with no real links to to get you going. Still have a chance to redeem themselves. They could certainly change that. They could because there are already apps out there that all you have to do is there's a certain URL pattern that you follow plus the RSS feed, and it will then let you subscribe to that or follow that feed in that app without that podcast actually being
21:52 inside that app. You can do that with Overcast. You can do that with Apple Podcasts, with many podcast apps out there, that simple formula, Google Podcasts already has those RSS feed URLs. They could have very simply done that kind of thing or, like, googlepodcast.com. Well, that's not the actual link, but that dot com slash my feed URL now redirects to youtube music.com/subscribe to podcast question mark feed equals and then the feed. Whatever. They could have done that kind of thing to make it a seamless transition. That kind of thing really bugs me when people don't think about all of the links that are out there. I'm the type, when I bio domain, if I speak a domain, I have it for life. Because I think, you know, on my deathbed, someone out there is gonna think, I heard this URL from Daniel once. I'm gonna go visit that. I want that URL to still work. Right. It's funny because we started off with this, like, wouldn't it be great if this turned into a big thing? And the more we talk about this, I'm just sitting here thinking, yeah, it's not.
23:04 I I hope they prove me wrong. I know the response we heard was, you know, later this year, they will officially, I guess, everywhere. I think some of this is just in the US. But eventually, it will, like, just be gone. They're just gonna, you know, obliterate obliterate? I just made up a new word. They're just gonna wipe it off the planet, and maybe that's when they put in a redirect. And if they do that, then again, it's like, oh, great. Now that we've all figured out other apps to use, you're gonna make it easy to move to the new one. So, again, I could be wrong. Maybe they'll do something, but I'd But I do wanna take this back to a positive side. Okay. If this becomes a big thing and if they do this right, if they if they fix it really, what I think this could be great is that here are people on YouTube already consuming content, mostly video content. Yes. There's plenty of fake video out there that's not also a podcast. But regardless, people are on there to consume content that they listen to or watch. It would be wonderful to have podcasts, actual podcasts, right alongside that and get recommended in the same algorithms.
24:17 But, sorry, I have to go back to this, YouTube has to think about it differently. Like, you think about the YouTube algorithm where you watch a video and then 20 minutes later, you've learned how to build a nuclear bomb. Because you've just gone down this rabbit hole of video after video. And I'm sorry, not 20 minutes chapters, 20 hours later because you can get down that rabbit hole where YouTube just recommends video chapters video after video related to that and also using that whole algorithms as as it starts to learn what you're interested in. That same kind of thing could happen with podcast too, but they need to do it in a way that actually gives audio podcasts equal position and equal interest to an audience who's looking for video. And that's the thing that I've seen in the past and one of the reasons why I'm so against fake video on YouTube is that I've seen this kind of thing where managing a fake video channel before where the video got huge view counts and then a massive drop off, 95% or so within the first 90 seconds. I think that's what it was. And almost no one was listening after 5 minutes. And we're talking from 20,000, 30,000 views down to a handful. And that's because that video was probably algorithmically recommended or was searched for, and it showed up as relevant, but then people quickly abandoned it as soon as they figured out
25:50 what it was. If you can set people's expectation ahead of time before they press on it, then they're more likely to stick around. I've done split tests with this on websites and stuff and I've seen studies on this as well. Set those expectations. So if in that recommended list, maybe there's a thing where it's like recommended video and then there's another section that's recommended audio, something like that. And even for myself, I think I would be more likely to click and listen to the video or I'm sorry. Like, the Freudian slip there. I would be more likely to listen to the audio on YouTube if I knew it was only audio. But right now, when I see certain videos on YouTube, that there are certain video games that I play and I'm interested in and such.
26:45 And I'll go to their YouTube channel and they're cover they're covering, like, the latest updates or something like that. And I want to see what they're talking about, and I keep expecting to see it because it's a video, and it is a true video. There's something going on on the screen. But what frustrates me so many times is the video is pointless. It's just video of them playing the game while they talk over that video. So that kind of experience could be so much better as only audio and if they could let me know ahead of time this is an audio, then I would be more likely to listen through it because I'm not then watching it getting frustrated with every second, waiting to see something that's actually relevant to what they're talking about and never getting it.
27:34 But if I know this is only a listening experience, then I can press play, switch tabs, switch apps, whatever, and listen while I'm then doing everything else that I would do with the podcast. Yeah. Elsie just made this point on the feed that she's noticing a trend where people are having AI generate titles, and it sounds great. And it's this huge title that, you know, you can do this in a $1,000,000 in 5 seconds She goes, and the problem is it mentions something very specific. Like like, let's say your video game is, like, you know, the 5 steps to solve level 3, and you're like, perfect. Great. And then you go and you watch, and they gave you something very specific, and they never talk about that.
28:19 They That is, you know, how to lose your audience. Yeah. And that's where I think you'll see a spike. Right? You're gonna hit the algorithm because that title is amazing, and you got a great thumbnail. And then people see it, and welcome to American Idol. You had your 5 minutes of fame, and now you're gone. And, sure, you might gleam a few people because at least you're playing the game they like, but they're not gonna stick around. And I would much rather as much as I would love to have 10,000 downloads, but, you know, the the people that grow organically, it is slower. It's slower than I think anything. You know, growing an email list is probably chapters. Growing a blog is probably chapters. But growing an e podcast, it's it's a you know, we always say it's a marathon, not a sprint, and that's not just a fun bumper sticker. That's the truth. And so, you know, we've gotta be truthful with our titles, and, you know, that's again where algorithms, on one hand, yay, we've solved the discoverability problem, he said in quotation marks. But on the other hand, well, I hope you liked your 10 minutes of fame. You know, you you you rode the wave, but now you gotta swim back out in the ocean and try to catch another one. Book on a Kindle?
29:34 No. It's not a great experience. I've tried it multiple times where you'll get it. Because it's a cool thing that you actually get an email. If you have a Kindle, you know, you get an email address that you can get a, you know, some sort of PDF, and you just attach it and send it to that email, and it will show up on your Kindle. And I was like, this is amazing. But some of the features in the Kindle, like making the font bigger or some other things, it just didn't quite because it wasn't exactly made for a Kindle. It's you're kind of you need a square peg a little bit into that that hole. So So so what is an ebook? That aside, what I meant was, like, an actual ebook that you've purchased from Amazon that was then delivered automatically through Kindle. Perfect. I love that because I do it all the time. I actually have Kindle Unlimited, so I can read as many books as I want. So one of the things I love about doing that, and I've got a Kindle, and I really prefer to read something on it. For one thing, it's avoids the distractions.
30:31 But one of the features I really love, the community highlights. Yes. That when you're reading a book that's from Amazon, not something you've uploaded manually, you get to see things that other people have found interesting. And what goes through your mind when you see that? When you're reading along, and then you see that little underline, and you see this many thousands of people highlighted this. What goes through your mind today? Oh, I if especially if I see it at the bottom of the page, I'm like, oh, something good is coming up. And then I also go, you know what? While I'm here, I'm gonna highlight that too. That is good stuff. Me too. What if Google put that into podcasts on YouTube where they could pull the excerpts out and recommend excerpts of that along with all of the other videos. So one of these problems with podcasting is that podcasts are long form audio mostly. There are plenty of Yep. True video podcasts out there.
31:30 But it's long form audio, and that is difficult to go viral. Videos on YouTube are usually chapters. But also, if they're true video, they're a lot more engaging. They're engaging so much more of your senses. You can understand people better also when you're watching them instead of only listening to them. Yeah. There are all of these other problems about video, like it's not portable, bandwidth issues, all of that. That aside, if you're watching a really interesting video, YouTube could then recommend in their algorithm an excerpt from an audio podcast. And when you click on it, it jumps you straight to that section of the audio, kind of like this many 1000 people found this also interesting or that you might also like, but instead of recommending an entire episode that starts off with, hey, everybody. How are you doing? It's really good to hear you.
32:25 Hey. Don't forget to rate and review the podcast. This week, we've got coming you know, all of that stuff that sometimes podcasters waste a lot of time up front. What if they could just jump to that section? And then in the app, while they're listening to that section, then YouTube is saying, click here to listen to the full episode. Just like there's, bible.com as a Bible website Yeah. Where you can search an individual verse, but then there's the link right there that lets you view that whole verse in context. Christians, you need to click that every time you look up an individual verse. But that kind of thing could be brought to YouTube also so that they are recommending the specific content that's relevant to what someone is watching. And they're also then doing that carryover, helping discovery, actually, because they're making that transition that you are watching this thing. Here is a short audio snippet you might also like that's about the same thing. Thousands of other people liked this too. Click here to listen.
33:32 That would be great. It'll be interesting to, to see. I know they are doing YouTube is doing some webinars. I know they're doing one with JSON. So by the time you hear this, it's already happened, but I know they're they're doing some to kinda get the word out. So it'd be interesting to see if they change anything. Because right now, the way it's set up, you're just doing YouTube with audio. You can't, you know, replace a file. It's very much it's just YouTube, except it's, you know, a static image instead of a an actual video. So it'd be interesting to see if they bend the rules at all. I'm not optimistic, but they could surprise me. You never know.
34:14 Our friend and founder of Podfest Multimedia Expo, Chris Kremitzos, wrote a great book, Start Ugly, a timeless tale about innovation and change. And I will say, YouTube podcasts have started very ugly. But this is a good but. They have a lot of potential and I want them to succeed with this. I want them to make this a more integrated experience, a crossover experience to actually crossover people from watching to listening. YouTube, I think, is uniquely positioned to do that because YouTube is the only place people are going or it's the most popular place people are going to stream free video content. I watch it every day on my TV. I go to lunch, and I have a YouTube button on my remote.
35:11 So and I think more and more people are doing that, that it's it's now because the beauty of it is with YouTube and the algorithm, I have my subscriptions. And instead of I could surf on Netflix trying to find something good, or I could click the YouTube button and go right to my subscriptions and go, oh, look. Tom Buck has a new video out. Click. You know? So you it's it's similar to, like, Netflix, but it just seems like you have to search so far in Netflix to find something good. And you're like, oh, here's a new movie featuring this actor that I like from what? I didn't know this. 1981. Like, oh, wait a minute. That's that's that's not good. So Where it'll be fun to watch. Where all the other podcast apps are great with the podcast consumption experience. They're not good at discovery, cross promotion, recommendation, all of that. I know there's some work being done in some of those apps to improve that. YouTube, not great on the audio podcast consumption experience. Still early.
36:10 Yes. Fantastic on the algorithm side. So if they could I I think it's easier to improve the podcast ex consumption experience than it is to improve the algorithm. This thing that I described, like transitioning people from video to audio, that's probably just a few simple tweaks in their algorithm, and they can do that. Well, they said in their presentation of podcast movement evolutions where the algorithm will often send you stuff from other people. And they said, maybe if you're flagged as a podcast, maybe it will purposely send you to the next episode.
36:51 And I'm, like, well, that would be great. I heard that. And you know what I thought? Oh, you mean, like a podcast app does? It takes you to the next episode? Yeah. But I was also, like, wait a minute. In YouTube, on my videos, I say, show them the best video that you feel is the best from my channel. And I'm like, wait. You just said you send them to other people. And, really, I think what he's talking about is that right channel. The the basically, the distraction channel. So, sure, at the end of the video, they'll send you one of yours. But in the meantime, here's 7 other ones that you might like, and you're probably gonna click on those before, you know, the actual video is over. So only time will tell.
37:35 So, Daniel, did we get any boostograms? We did. 25100 sats from Dwev, and I learned that is the correct pronunciation. He said, I agree with all your points about Cast O Matic, Daniel. It is my current primary player, but it's my favorite. The UX, that's user experience, around setting up value for value is so easy and having the boost button right there means I'm boosting much more. I know. It's so tempting to press that button. Also, the SAT slash fiat reference works in multiple currencies, which is also awesome. That's great to know. I'd like to be able to manually refresh a feed slash episode to get updated show notes or super chapters, etcetera. Thank you so much, Dwev, for that comment as well as the 25100 stats boost. Yeah. That's awesome. I do believe if you swipe down, if you're looking in the app, I think if you just pull down, it does do something where some little, you know, circle thing spins around. So it looks like it's refreshing. I believe the the fun part with any kind of podcast is especially I know last week.
38:38 Thanks, Dave. I put out our episode, and I had we had some issues with that episode. And at one point, I have a live chat on my website, and I forgot to turn it off. And so if you heard this bell ringing about 12 minutes and 40 seconds in, that was Dave's fault. And so that went out, and somebody said, hey. Do you know you have this weird sound in it? And it was like, I easily fixed it and put it back out. But if you downloaded the first one, it's not going to redownload. I guess I could have you know, there are ways you can do this. You can create a new episode and say repost and but if you just fix the file, that fix everything from this point forward. But everybody else got the collector's edition, so congratulations on that. You know, a side note, I've put forward a proposal that Adam Curry actually liked, but no one's discussed it. It was maybe 2 years ago I put forward this proposal that basically you could have a tag to say this replaces this other episode. And so if you ever put out an episode with that replaces tag on it then it would automatically delete the previous episode or maybe it prompts the user to say hey there's a new version of this. Would you rather download or redownload this new version or listen to this new version or do you wanna pick up from this current time but on this other file? That kind of thing. That would be neat to see, but that's that's a very niche feature that we shouldn't need. Yeah. We shouldn't need, but we do. That's the problem.
40:04 So, yeah, I like that idea. Excellent. So, alright. Well, tell us what you think. Are you optimistic about YouTube music, or are you a person that's like, I don't know. Send us a boost and let us know. And, of course, we'll be reading those on the next episode of the future of podcasting. Thanks so much for listening. That's gonna do it for this episode. Keep boosting and keep podcasting.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castamatic
Fountain
Podverse
RSS Feed 